BackgroundBackgroundFOAMed appraisal

Casting Doubt on Tradition: Boot vs Cast for Toddler’s Fractures

REBEL EM10 Aug 2026General Emergency Medicine

For stable, uncomplicated toddler's fractures, consider counseling parents about a removable walking boot as a viable alternative to casting since it appears noninferior for pain control and may facilitate quicker return to activity. Remember to thoroughly counsel caregivers on diligent skin checks when using the boot to prevent pressure injuries or irritation.

EDCritix summary

This piece challenges the long-standing practice of casting all uncomplicated, radiographically confirmed toddler's fractures by evaluating the use of a removable walking boot as an alternative treatment modality. The evidence presented suggests that treating these injuries with a boot is noninferior to traditional casting when assessing pain levels at the four-week mark. Furthermore, the authors noted that boot immobilization allowed a greater proportion of children to resume their baseline level of activity more quickly compared to those casted. This shift in practice consideration is useful because it directly addresses reducing caregiver burden while maintaining comparable clinical outcomes regarding pain management.